May 20, 2001
Cash Cow, Quebec, Canada, 1997
Photograph by Maggie Steber
Quebec is the ’cash cow’ of Canada, many Québécois think, convinced that they pay more taxes to Ottawa, the national capital, than they receive in benefits. Yet even Quebec government studies show that the province receives a net cash flow of at least two billion dollars U.S. from Ottawa, while other studies reckon it to be much higher. Quebec’s dairy farmers are themselves guaranteed a 47 percent national market share for processed milk. Despite such subsidies, support for independence remains strong in the rural French-speaking area.
现金牛,魁北克,加拿大1997年
Maggie Steber摄
魁北克人认为,魁北克是加拿大的“现金牛(摇钱树)”。当地许多人坚信他们向渥太华(指加政府-淡色的树)纳税多于他们得到的福利,即使魁北克政府的研究表明全省至少从政府得到20亿美元净现金,其他来源的估算数据甚至更高。魁北克的牧场主们确保自己拥有47%的全国奶市场份额,即便这样,独立呼声在法语区仍然强劲 |